Agricola et al16 compared carbamazepine to tiapride for treatment of acute AWS. In this study, 60 patients were randomized to carbamazepine, 200 mg 3 times a day, or tiapride, 200 mg 3 times a day. All patients were hospitalized with severe AWS preceding DT. The patients were evaluated for withdrawal symptoms (gastrointestinal and cardiovascular symptoms, sleep disturbances, anxiety, aggression, fear, depression, psychotic symptoms, and certain neurologic symptoms). The severity of these symptoms was scored as follows: 0 = no symptoms; 1 = moderate symptoms; and 2 = severe symptoms. At each visit, an overall evaluation of the patient’s clinical condition was made according to a visual analogue scale (100 = worst condition, 0 = best condition). On Day 7, both the doctor and patient evaluated treatment efficacy according to a 4-point scale (1 = no efficacy, 4 = excellent efficacy). There was no significant difference between carbamazepine and tiapride in terms of total symptoms score and visual analogue scale assessment. Carbamazepine was found to have faster relief of symptoms and a significantly greater reduction in symptom score on Day 2 (P < .01). Carbamazepine had a preferential action on fear, nightmares, and hallucinations. The proportion of patients in whom anxiety improved after treatment was 96.2% for carbamazepine and 71.4% for tiapride (P < .05). Aggressiveness and gastrointestinal discomfort resolved faster in the tiapride group. No cases of DT were observed.
Conclusion: The researchers concluded that either carbamazepine or tiapride provides an appropriate alternative in the treatment of inpatients with severe AWS.16
Stuppaeck et al17 compared the efficacy of carbamazepine to oxazepam in 60 inpatients who had symptoms of alcohol withdrawal. Alcohol withdrawal was measured with the CIWA-A, and patients with scores >20 were enrolled in the study. The Clinical Global Impression (CGI) scale and self-rated Adjective Checklist (ACL) were also used. On Days 1 to 3, patients received oxazepam, 120 mg/d, or carbamazepine, 800 mg/d. From Day 4 to 7, doses were decreased to 90 mg/d and 600 mg/d, respectively. After the 7-day trial, all patients were treated with carbamazepine, 200 mg twice a day on Day 8 and 200 mg at night on Day 9. Two patients withdrew consent and 6 dropped out due to adverse effects. During the 7-day trial, when comparing all improvements on CIWA-A, ACL, and CGI scales, carbamazepine was equivalent to oxazepam up to Day 5, and then superior on Days 6 and 7 (P ≤ .05). No decrease in white blood cell count was found in the carbamazepine group.
Conclusion: The authors concluded that carbamazepine is as effective as oxazepam and may be a viable alternative that does not interact with alcohol or cause delirium.17
Malcolm et al18 compared the effects of carbamazepine and lorazepam in patients in an outpatient setting who had single vs multiple previous alcohol withdrawals. The study included 136 patients who satisfied DSM-IV criteria for alcohol dependence and alcohol withdrawal, with a blood alcohol level ≤0.1 g/dL, a Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) score ≤26, and a CIWA-Ar score ≤10 on admission. Patients also completed the ADS to quantify the severity of alcohol dependence. Daily drinking was measured by patient report using a daily drinking log and blood alcohol level. Heavy drinking was defined as ≥4 standard drinks per day for women and ≥5 drinks per day for men. On Day 1, patients were randomized to receive carbamazepine, 600 to 800 mg/d,or lorazepam, 6 to 8 mg/d, in divided doses, which was tapered to carbamazepine, 200 mg/d, or lorazepam, 2 mg/d, on Day 5. All patients received thiamine for 12 days. In the immediate post-detoxification period, carbamazepine-treated patients were less likely to relapse, and if they did drink, they drank less than those treated with lorazepam (P = .003). Even in patients who had multiple previous detoxifications, those randomized to carbamazepine drank less than those in lorazepam group (P = .004). Patients in the lorazepam group had significant higher rebound withdrawal symptoms (P = .007).
Continue to: Conclusion