Commentary

Critical Care Commentary: Brain death – patient, law, and family

View on the News

Brain death is not 'black and white'
Dr. Bowton


Dr. Peter Spiro, FCCP

In this thorough and somber commentary, Dr. Bowton clearly points out how much gray remains in a world that demands black and white certainty.

Brain death, and its implication, is not an exact diagnosis, which impacts the family, society, and the care-giving team, but most of all, the patient.

As there are times that brain death cannot be truly determined, we must be mindful that our primary goal is always the patient, then the families, society, and others. As a practitioner in New York, where family discussion is the law, I have not found this to be a great impediment; with palliative care and pastoral support, most issues can be resolved. As we progress in our knowledge, a more global unified approach would be welcomed.

Dr. Peter Spiro, FCCP Section Editor


 

Dr. Bowton is Professor, Section on Critical Care, Department of Anesthesiology, Wake Forest Baptist Health, Winston-Salem, North Carolina. Read previous Critical Care Commentaries online.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Most health care–associated infections aren’t device associated
MDedge Surgery
VIDEO: Study highlights progress, challenges in nosocomial infections
MDedge Surgery
Lung transplants in HIV-positive gaining momentum
MDedge Surgery
VIDEO: Rethink the VTE prophylaxis mantra
MDedge Surgery
Depression at least five times more common than PTSD after critical illness
MDedge Surgery
Bed rest after lung injury linked to muscle weakness, functional impairments
MDedge Surgery
VIDEO: It's time to focus on less severe sepsis
MDedge Surgery
PTSD symptoms a common complication of critical illness
MDedge Surgery
VIDEO: PTSD common in survivors of critical illness
MDedge Surgery
Traditional scoring tool limps as VAP screen in surgical ICU study
MDedge Surgery