Commentary

More on ‘treatment resistance’


 

I wanted to thank Dr. Nasrallah for his bold article, “Treatment resistance is a myth!” (From the Editor, Current Psychiatry, March 2021, p. 14-16,28). “Treatment resistance” has become an overused catchphrase, largely for commercial purposes, that sends a distorted view to the public that current psychiatric treatments are ineffective. We have proven, safe, and effective treatments as covered in the article. So, instead of “treatment resistance,” we should be publicizing that “treatment works!” to encourage people to seek help for mental disorders and addictions.

Stanley N. Caroff, MD
Professor of Psychiatry
Perelman School of Medicine
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

I thought Dr. Nasrallah’s editorial on treatment resistance was excellent. In my experience, bipolar depression often is not diagnosed in patients with long-standing depression. These patients do worse on antidepressants, which is interpreted by the clinician as treatment-resistant major depressive disorder. The other issue for me is that individuals with bipolar disorder with psychotic features are often diagnosed with schizophrenia or schizo­affective disorder and never receive a trial of lithium, which could alter the course of their illness in a dramatic fashion. For me, the under­utilization of lithium is a real quality problem in our field. Keep up the good work!

Bruce J. Schwartz, MD
Deputy Chairman & Professor of PsychiatryMontefiore Medical Center and Albert Einstein College of Medicine
New York, New York

Pages

Recommended Reading

Altha J. Stewart, MD, on the state of psychiatry
MDedge Psychiatry
Lithium and kidney disease: Understand the risks
MDedge Psychiatry
APA, AMA, others move to stop insurer from overturning mental health claims ruling
MDedge Psychiatry
What brought me back from the brink of suicide: A physician’s story
MDedge Psychiatry
Bill seeks to streamline prior authorization in Medicare Advantage plans
MDedge Psychiatry
FDA fast tracks testing of schizophrenia drug for impaired cognition
MDedge Psychiatry
Efficacy and safety of high-dose antipsychotic therapy
MDedge Psychiatry
Private practice: The basics for psychiatry trainees
MDedge Psychiatry
Harassment of health care workers: A survey
MDedge Psychiatry
Storing patients’ credit card information: Keep it safe
MDedge Psychiatry