Study 2 Overview (Stark et al)
Objective: To examine the effect of a behavioral home hazard removal intervention for fall prevention on risk of fall in community-dwelling older adults.
Design: This randomized clinical trial was conducted at a single site in St. Louis, Missouri. Participants were community-dwelling older adults who received services from the Area Agency on Aging (AAA). Inclusion criteria included age 65 years and older, having 1 or more falls in the previous 12 months or being worried about falling by self report, and currently receiving services from an AAA. Exclusion criteria included living in an institution or being severely cognitively impaired and unable to follow directions or report falls. Participants who met the criteria were contacted by phone and invited to participate. A total of 310 participants were enrolled in the study, with an equal number of participants assigned to the intervention and control groups.
Intervention: The intervention included hazard identification and removal after a comprehensive assessment of participants, their behaviors, and the environment; this assessment took place during the first visit, which lasted approximately 80 minutes. A home hazard removal plan was developed, and in the second session, which lasted approximately 40 minutes, remediation of hazards was carried out. A third session for home modification that lasted approximately 30 minutes was conducted, if needed. At 6 months after the intervention, a booster session to identify and remediate any new home hazards and address issues was conducted. Specific interventions, as identified by the assessment, included minor home repair such as grab bars, adaptive equipment, task modification, and education. Shared decision making that enabled older adults to control changes in their homes, self-management strategies to improve awareness, and motivational enhancement strategies to improve acceptance were employed. Scripted algorithms and checklists were used to deliver the intervention. For usual care, an annual assessment and referrals to community services, if needed, were conducted in the AAA.
Main outcome measures: The primary outcome of the study was the number of days to first fall in 12 months. Falls were defined as unintentional movements to the floor, ground, or object below knee level, and falls were recorded through a daily journal for 12 months. Participants were contacted by phone if they did not return the journal or reported a fall. Participants were interviewed to verify falls and determine whether a fall was injurious. Secondary outcomes included rate of falls per person per 12 months; daily activity performance measured using the Older Americans Resources and Services Activities of Daily Living scale; falls self-efficacy, which measures confidence performing daily activities without falling; and quality of life using the SF-36 at 12 months.
Main results: Most of the study participants were women (74%), and mean (SD) age was 75 (7.4) years. Study retention was similar between the intervention and control groups, with 82% completing the study in the intervention group compared with 81% in the control group. Fidelity to the intervention, as measured by a checklist by the interventionist, was 99%, and adherence to home modification, as measured by number of home modifications in use by self report, was high at 92% at 6 months and 91% at 12 months. For the primary outcome, fall hazard was not different between the intervention and control groups (hazard ratio, 0.9; 95% CI, 0.66-1.27). For the secondary outcomes, the rate of falling was lower in the intervention group compared with the control group, with a relative risk of 0.62 (95% CI, 0.40-0.95). There was no difference in other secondary outcomes of daily activity performance, falls self-efficacy, or quality of life.
Conclusion: Despite high adherence to home modifications and fidelity to the intervention, this home hazard removal program did not reduce the risk of falling when compared to usual care. It did reduce the rate of falls, although no other effects were observed.