Commentary

What if the Supreme Court Tosses Out the ACA?


 

Opponents of the Affordable Care Act are hoping that the Supreme Court will soon invalidate the law and put a permanent end to the federal government’s expanded role in health care. But one Capitol Hill watcher says the defeat of the ACA by the high court could lead to something conservatives would like even less – single-payer health care. Well, not anytime soon. But tossing out the law could help nudge things in that direction over time.

Norman J. Ornstein, Ph.D., an author and resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, said he could imagine a scenario where if the ACA were defeated, over time, Democrats would move to expand Medicare beyond the 65 and older crowd. Mr. Ornstein, who has a new book coming soon on the growing dysfunction in Washington, offered his two cents while speaking to a group of physicians at the Society of Hospital Medicine’s annual meeting in San Diego this week.

Photo by FRANCES CORREA/ IMNG Medical Media

Protesters outside the Supreme Court in March.

Another way that single-payer health care could become a reality is at the state level. Individual states might experiment with single payer-type programs along the lines of the Green Mountain Care program in Vermont, Mr. Ornstein said. Lawmakers in that state have enacted legislation allowing them to phase in a single-payer health care system over the next several years. But they have yet to hammer out details on how to pay for the program and it’s unclear how long it will take to move from the current framework of public and private insurance to a single-payer system.

– Mary Ellen Schneider

Recommended Reading

More Physicians Get Paid for Quality Reporting, E-Prescribing
MDedge Internal Medicine
Reflections of an Innovation Adviser
MDedge Internal Medicine
Obesity Drugs' CV Risk Assessment Needs Hard End Points
MDedge Internal Medicine
Elderly Stroke Patients Have High Atrial Fibrillation Prevalence
MDedge Internal Medicine
HPV Coverage Low Among U.S. Servicewomen
MDedge Internal Medicine
More In-Hospital Deaths in MI Patients With Diabetes
MDedge Internal Medicine
Showing Patients Their Coronary Calcium Scans Motivates Adherence
MDedge Internal Medicine
IOM: Primary Care, Public Health Need to Work Together
MDedge Internal Medicine
HIV Is Independent Risk Factor for Arterial Inflammation
MDedge Internal Medicine
Gender Bias May Influence Hospitalist Pay
MDedge Internal Medicine