Commentary

Genetic Testing for Cardiac Risk Assessment Discouraged


 

The true power of genetic association studies to identify risk factors for common diseases may in fact not lie in better identification of those at increased risk. Rather, elucidation of the biological basis of such associations holds the promise of improving our understanding and eventual treatment of the underlying disease process.

So how should a physician deal with the availability of cardiac risk assessment tests? Clearly, these are best suited for people who consider themselves early adopters. The 9p21 marker appears to be the most clinically relevant marker at this point. Indeed, the risk associated with this genetic variant appears highest in younger individuals, so perhaps it might be appropriate to consider obtaining such information in a person under age 55 years who needs further encouragement to modify his or her cardiac risks.

Ideally, patients and their providers will engage in a discussion of the potential risks and benefits prior to any testing. Then, in the truest and oldest model of personalized medicine, they can decide together if pursuing such testing is appropriate on a case-by-case basis.

This column, "Genetics in Your Practice," regularly appears in Internal Medicine News, an Elsevier publication. Dr. Levy is an assistant professor in the division of general internal medicine and McKusick-Nathans Institute of Genetic Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore. Dr. Taylor is associate professor in the department of internal medicine and director of adult clinical genetics at the University of Colorado at Denver.

To respond to this column, e-mail Dr. Taylor at imnews@elsevier.com.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Nurse-Led Intervention Improved Concomitant Chronic Diseases
MDedge Internal Medicine
Syncope, Seizure May Precede Cardiac Arrest in Children, Young Adults
MDedge Internal Medicine
Low MI Risk With Aromatase Inhibitors in Community-Treated Breast Cancer Patients
MDedge Internal Medicine
Daily Yogurt Drink Lowered LDL Cholesterol in Children
MDedge Internal Medicine
Higher Mortality Seen in Women With Diabetes, Depression
MDedge Internal Medicine
Nearly a Fourth of Patients Given ICDs Don't Meet Implantation Criteria
MDedge Internal Medicine
IDSA Targets MRSA With New Guidelines
MDedge Internal Medicine
FDA Tightens Rules for Tobacco Products
MDedge Internal Medicine
Omega-3 Fatty Acid Supplements May Ease Heart Failure Symptoms
MDedge Internal Medicine
Assess and Treat Cardiovascular Risk in Psoriasis
MDedge Internal Medicine