Clinical Inquiries
Medication vs radioablation for Graves’ disease: How do they compare?
EVIDENCE-BASED ANSWER: THE BENEFITS ARE SIMILAR; the risks vary. Treating Graves’ disease initially with medication or radioablation (or surgery)...
Brian J. Pottorf, MD
John T. Moore, MD
Harris W. Hollis Jr, MD
Exempla Saint Joseph Hospital, Department of Graduate Medical Education, General Surgery, Denver, Colo
brian.pottorf@gmail.com
The authors reported no potential conflict of interest relevant to this article.
THE CASE
A 26-year-old Hispanic woman presented to the emergency department (ED) with myalgia and weakness. The work-up revealed profound hyperthyroidism, with a thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) <0.01 mIU/mL (normal, 0.4-4.2 mIU/L), potassium 2.4 mEq/L (normal, 3.7-5.2 mEq/L), hypophosphatemia, and low urinary potassium. There were no prior symptoms and family history was negative for endocrinopathies. She was admitted and started on methimazole 10 mg twice a day for thyroid suppression and given propranolol 10 mg twice a day for anticipated hyperadrenergic adverse effects. The remainder of her hospital stay was uneventful and she was discharged 6 days after admission. Soon after, an outpatient thyroid scan ordered by her primary care physician confirmed that the patient had Graves’ disease.
Eight months later, the patient returned to the ED with myalgia and rapidly progressing paralysis from the neck down; she was immediately intubated. Her potassium level was 1.2 mEq/L. An electrocardiogram (EKG) revealed conduction abnormalities consistent with hypokalemia.
THE DIAGNOSIS
Based on our patient’s paralysis, hyperthyroidism, and hypokalemia, we diagnosed thyrotoxic hypokalemic periodic paralysis (THPP), a rare endocrinopathy that causes electrolyte disturbances that can result in paralysis and lethal tachyarrhythmias.1-6
Patients with THPP typically have a history of myalgia, cramping, and stiffness followed by weakness or paralysis that tends to develop rapidly, most commonly in the late evening or early morning1-4,6,7 (TABLE1-9). Proximal muscles are predominantly affected symmetrically and the attacks usually resolve in a period of hours to several days. Ocular, bulbar, and respiratory muscles are usually spared, but these can be affected by the hypokalemia.1
DISCUSSION
Traditionally THPP has been seen primarily in Asia, with an incidence as high as 2%.1-6 The incidence in the United States is lower (0.1%-0.2%) and THPP occurs primarily in Asian, African, Hispanic, and Native American populations.1,4,6
Although thyrotoxicosis is more common in women, THPP has a predilection for men (20:1).1,3-6 THPP occurs in patients with hyperthyroidism, most commonly from Graves’ disease,1,6 who are exposed to certain precipitating factors, such as exercise, carbohydrate loading, high-salt diet, excessive alcohol consumption, trauma, cold exposure, infection, menstruation, or emotional stress.1,6 THPP can also occur in people taking medications such as corticosteroids, β2-adrenergic bronchodilators, epinephrine, acetazolamide, insulin, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, thyroxine, amiodarone, and tiratricol.1,5,6 THPP is more common in the summer.1
A genetic basis for THPP. A Kir2.6 mutation results in a thyroid hormone-sensitive channelopathy involving the sodium-potassium-adenosine triphosphate (Na+,K+-ATPase) pump, which appears to be responsible for THPP.1-6,8,9 This mutation should not be confused with the pathogenesis of familial periodic paralysis (FPP)—a hereditary disorder resulting in abnormalities in calcium, sodium, and potassium channels on skeletal muscle cells that leads to multiple electrolyte derangements and paralysis identical to that observed in THPP.1
Hypokalemia may be exacerbated by catecholamine-induced potassium shifts.1,4,6 This is from the increased β2-adrenergic stimulation from the concurrent hyperadrenergic state caused by the underlying hyperthyroidism.1,4,6 Hyperinsulinemia from sympathetic stimulation of the insulin-releasing pancreatic beta cells also exacerbates hypokalemia.1,4,6
Focus treatment on correcting electrolytes
Acute management of THPP centers on electrolyte correction; definitive treatments include antithyroid medication, radioactive iodine ablation, and/or thyroidectomy. Initial evaluation of a patient suspected of having THPP should include a complete blood count, TSH and serum and urine electrolyte tests, and an EKG. Further work-up may require ultrasound and scan of the thyroid upon confirmation of thyrotoxicosis and hypokalemia. Physical examination may reveal thyromegaly. Exophthalmos and other hyperthyroidism symptoms often are absent.1
Diagnosis confirmed? Treat the hypokalemia first. Acute management of THPP centers on electrolyte correction. Total body stores of potassium in patients with THPP are usually normal, so the physician must use care to avoid excessive potassium administration.1-5 Rebound hyperkalemia can occur in patients who receive >90 mEq/L of potassium chloride within 24 hours.1
Definitive therapy may include antithyroid medication, radioactive iodine ablation (RIA), and/or thyroidectomy.1-5 All have the common goal of controlling the hyperthyroidism and preventing recurrent paralysis, which occurs in 62.2% of patients within the first 3 months following diagnosis.3 If antithyroid medications fail, then RIA is the next choice.1 Beta-blockers work by decreasing the Na+,K+-ATPase activity from the underlying hyperadrenergic state.1 Administration of acetazolamide—which is the primary treatment modality for FPP and idiopathic periodic paralysis—can precipitate THPP attacks and is contraindicated.1,5
Consider thyroidectomy for patients for whom medical management is unsuccessful or who develop compression symptoms. If medical management is unsuccessful or the patient develops compression symptoms, then thyroidectomy should be considered.3 If the patient chooses thyroidectomy, medical optimization with antithyroid medications is indicated to mitigate the risks of anesthesia. When the thyroidectomy is performed by an experienced thyroid surgeon, the long-term results are excellent.
EVIDENCE-BASED ANSWER: THE BENEFITS ARE SIMILAR; the risks vary. Treating Graves’ disease initially with medication or radioablation (or surgery)...
Clinical presentation and an algorithm-guided laboratory assessment can quickly narrow the diagnosis and help direct your choice, timing, and...