Original Research

Do Parents and Physicians Differ in Making Decisions About Acute Otitis Media?

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Attitudes and opinions related to AOM and health care were not associated with the percentage of cases in which the participant of any group chose to treat with antibiotics. Among both the Americans and the French, the parents thought physicians worried more about charges of malpractice when making decisions about patient care than physicians claimed they did (P <.005 for both countries). Parents were bothered when their child was sick more than physicians were bothered when “one of my patients” was sick (P <.005 for both). If there was a possibility that their child had “a serious illness that is rare but curable,” parents were more willing than physicians to order diagnostic tests even when they would cost the parents “a great deal of time and/or money” (P <.005 for both). Interestingly, parents agreed less strongly than physicians with the statement “A doctor should pay close attention to the needs and preferences of a child’s parents” (P <.005 for both). US parents, but not those in France, agreed more strongly than physicians that if their child might have a serious illness that was rare but curable diagnostic tests should be ordered even when they were “very expensive for the child’s insurance plan” (P <.005). French parents, but not American ones, agreed more strongly than physicians that “all ear infections should be treated with antibiotics” (P <.005).

TABLE 1
DIFFERENCES AMONG GROUPS OF PARTICIPANTS

US Physicians (n=19)US Parents (n=52)French Physicians (n=56)French Parents (n=86)
Mean judged probability of AOM (range)50 (28 to 75)51 (29 to 78)52.5 (33 to 85)52 (30 to 73)
Mean judged probability of treatment (range)0.22 (-2.4 to 3.0)-0.32 (-2.7 to 3.1)0.36 (-1.5 to 3.0)-0.42 (-2.9 to 2.6)
NOTE: The treatment score is the combination of the choice of observation versus antibiotics and the degree of certainty that this is the right choice, ranging from -5 (observe/completely sure) to 5 (antibiotics/completely sure).
AOM denotes acute otitis media.

TABLE 2
MEAN BETA WEIGHTS FOR CUES FOR JUDGING PROBABILITY OF ACUTE OTITIS MEDIA

CueUS Physicians (n=19)US Parents (n=52)French Physicians (n=55)French Parents (n=81)
History
  Past history of AOM0.020.080.03†0.15
  URI symptoms0.07-0.0100.03
  Ear pain noted by parent0.090.070.040.04
Findings on Examination
  Fever0.200.210.16†0.30†
  Redness of tympanic membrane0.48*0.34*0.400.36
  Bulging of tympanic membrane0.250.310.48†0.17†
  Mobility on insufflation0.37*0.22*0.130.14
  Asymmetry of tympanic membranes0.17*0.28*0.170.16
  Ear pain during examination0.090.140.09†0.28†
  General appearance of the child0.080.060.020.06
  Did the child start to cry just before the examination?0.02-0.03-0.01-0.02
Other Factors
  Parents’ personal position concerning antibiotics-0.050.030.020.02
  Ability of parents to provide effective care to a sick child0.01-0.04-0.02-0.01
  Does caring for sick child greatly upset parents’ ordinary schedule?00.0200.01
  Are there babies or other small children in the family?00.0200.02
Note: Higher values indicate a greater weight given to this cue in making the diagnosis of acute otitis media. Participants whose judgments failed to pass the F-test for multiple regression models (1 French pediatrician and 5 French parents) were excluded from the analysis.
AOM denotes acute otitis media; URI, upper respiratory infection.
*Significant comparison for US group, P <.05.
†Significant comparison for French group, P <.05.

TABLE 3
MEAN BETA WEIGHTS FOR CUES FOR CHOOSING TREATMENT OF ACUTE OTITIS MEDIA

CueUS Physicians (n=19)US Parents (n=49)French Physicians (n=50)French Parents (n=75)
History
  Past history of AOM0.020.040.040.08
  URI symptoms0.020.030.060.07
  Ear pain noted by parent0.110.100.07†0.0†
Findings on examination
  Fever0.210.280.25†0.52†
  Redness of Tympanic membrane0.360.290.34†0.23†
  Bulging of tympanic membrane0.190.230.41†0.08†
  Mobility on insufflation0.28*0.16*0.120.10
  Asymmetry of tympanic membranes0.200.230.130.09
  Ear pain during examination0.040.110.04†0.14†
  General appearance of the child0.160.100.10†0.04†
  Did the child start to cry just before the examination?0.0200.030
Other factors
  Parents’ personal position concerning antibiotics0.17*0.06*0.11†0.03†
  Ability of parents of provide effective care to a sick child-0.05-0.03-0.05-0.04
  Does caring for sick child greatly upset parents’ ordinary schedule?0.010.040.01-0.08
  Are there babies or other small children in the family?0.010.040.040.01
Note: Higher values indicate a greater weight given to this cue when deciding whether to treat with antibiotics. Participants whose judgments failed to pass the F-test for multiple regression models (3 French generalists, 3 French pediatricians, 3 US parents, and 11 French parents) were excluded from the analysis.
AOM denotes acute otitis media; URI, upper respiratory infection.
*Significant comparison for US group, P <.05.
†Significant comparison for French group, P <.05.

Discussion

Although physicians are aware that antibiotic resistance of bacteria is an increasing problem,39-41 they continue to prescribe antibiotics for patients who are unlikely to benefit from them.2,3,13,39,42,43 There are multiple plausible reasons for this.7,17,44-46 Some of these relate to physicians’ perceptions of the wants and needs of their patients and their caretakers. Physicians may47 (or may not48) make different decisions for individuals they are dealing with than for community groups. They know the public misunderstands the indications for antibiotics,25,49,50 and they may perceive, often incorrectly,19,21 that patients or parents want antibiotics and will be dissatisfied if they do not receive them.22,23,26,29,45,51 They may practice defensive medicine28 or believe that it takes less time and effort to prescribe antibiotics than to explain why they are withholding them.28,45 They may be sensitive to the socioeconomic pressures on patients and parents related to daycare policies, work schedules, and the costs of return visits.46

Pages

Recommended Reading

Is tolterodine (Detrol) or oxybutynin (Ditropan) the best for treatment of urge urinary incontinence?
MDedge Family Medicine
Does episiotomy increase perineal laceration length in primiparous women?
MDedge Family Medicine
In low to moderate risk patients with chest pain, is a 6-hour protocol able to accurately rule out acute myocardial infarction (AMI)?
MDedge Family Medicine
What is the diagnostic yield of a standardized sequential clinical evaluation of patients presenting to an emergency department with syncope?
MDedge Family Medicine
How common is peripheral arterial disease, and should primary care physicians be screening for it?
MDedge Family Medicine
Do dietary restrictions reduce fecal occult blood testing adherence?
MDedge Family Medicine
Does losartan (Cozaar) slow the progression of renal disease in patients with type 2 diabetes and nephropathy?
MDedge Family Medicine
The Mini Electronic Medical Record: A Low-Cost, Low-Risk Partial Solution
MDedge Family Medicine
After Chanukah
MDedge Family Medicine
Does long-term use of sibutramine (Meridia) result in continued weight loss in short-term responders?
MDedge Family Medicine