Commentary

The hospitalist movement and family practice— An uneasy fit

Author and Disclosure Information

 

As the hospitalist model develops, some kind of subsidy from the system will be needed to support this activity. It is difficult for a physician to support an adequate salary by charging for 10 to 12 hospital visits per day when most of these visits are inadequately reimbursed through Medicare. The arithmetic simply does not work out. A large group, the hospital system, or a managed care organization has subsidized most successful hospitalist programs.

Hospitalists are here to stay. This new specialization seems to have come about to fill a need rather than from a mandate. As with the other arbitrary divisions of responsibility that have produced our fragmented care system, the hospitalist will be found in urban and suburban hospitals, but not in the rural areas. There will be attempts to exclude those physicians who do not fit the arbitrary definition from hospital care. Physician assistants will be hired to help out with the hospitalist’s tasks, thereby negating any argument about training and competence. In the end the hospitalist movement will reach a steady state driven by need and not mandate. Family physicians will choose to work in the hospital or not just as they make other scope-of-practice choices now.

Family physicians will continue to provide continuing, comprehensive, and personal care to most of their patients, in the context of family and community and taking advantage of the important integration of mind, body, and spirit. The specialization that has occurred during the last 50 years has not changed the essence of what we do for our patients. The hospitalist movement is not likely to precipitate that change either.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Risperidone improves behavior in children with autism
MDedge Family Medicine
Duplex ultrasound and Magnetic Responce Angiography are sensitive for severe carotid stenosis
MDedge Family Medicine
How accurate is the D-dimer assay in diagnosing pulmonary embolism?
MDedge Family Medicine
Routine diagnostic hysteroscopy not necessary for premenopausal women with abnormal uterine bleeding
MDedge Family Medicine
Classification of medical errors and preventable adverse events in primary care: A synthesis of the literature
MDedge Family Medicine
Intention-to-treat analysis: Who is in? Who is out?
MDedge Family Medicine
The Spirituality Index of Well-Being: Development and testing of a new measure
MDedge Family Medicine
β-blockers no better than placebo in the treatment of vasovagal syncope
MDedge Family Medicine
Vitamin E may worsen acute respiratory tract infections in the elderly
MDedge Family Medicine
Maternal screening strategy more effective than risk-based approaches for preventing group B streptococcal disease in neonates
MDedge Family Medicine