Missing a Significant Proportion of the Population at Risk for Obesity-Related Diseases
In an interview, Luca Busetto, MD, obesity specialist and research assistant at the Center for the Study and the Integrated Treatment of the Obesity, University of Padova, Italy, and local ECO president, commented on the study and the issue of BMI as a measure and threshold. “I think the problem we face with a classic cutoff using BMI is that we miss a significant group of people who have BMI less than 30 but have a high fat mass,” he said, adding, “but these people have the same risk of developing chronic diseases as those people with higher BMI. If they have a bad fat distribution, then their risk of complications is even higher.
“Dr El Ghoch’s study underlines the lack of treatment for this significant part of the population,” he remarked. “We also need to use waist circumference and waist-to-height [ratio] as additional measures in this population.”
Dr. Busetto also presented a population-based study at ECO that included over 400,000 people with a follow-up of 8 years. “We found the risk of developing obesity complications, including type 2 diabetes, hypertension, osteoarthritis, and cardiovascular disease, is not only dependent on BMI but [also] dependent on your waist-to-height ratio,” he said, highlighting that “some of these complications are only predicted by the waist-to-height ratio and not by your BMI — in particular cardiovascular diseases.
“I honestly think any screening process today needs to include both BMI and waist-to-height ratio. Having a DXA scan is great in a specialist setting, but routinely we need a measure that is valid in every office in every country and small town.”
Francesco Rubino, MD, chair of metabolic and bariatric surgery at King›s College London, United Kingdom, also remarked that understanding the changes in fat and lean mass proportions and distribution in middle years will affect health in later life, and importantly from a clinical perspective, it is a time where there is still some opportunity to intervene.
Reflecting further on how it underscores the limitations of BMI in misclassifying people as having obesity or not, Rubino asked, “Importantly, does this make a difference to health and longevity? Really, we need an active measure of adiposity first, and then even if we do say someone has obesity — so excess adiposity — then does this translate into illness, because [excess adiposity] does not translate into disease for every individual?
“Any measure we use as a diagnostic criterion needs to reflect the ongoing disease in an individual, not only the risk of future disease — because not every person experiences this. As a doctor, we deal with the individual and how the diagnosis of disease relates to the individual in a clinic now, as well as the risk of tomorrow,” he concluded.
Dr. El Ghoch declares no conflicts of interest. Dr. Rubino disclosed that he has received research grants from Novo Nordisk, Medtronic, and Johnson & Johnson. He has undertaken paid consultancy work for GI Dynamics and received honoraria for lectures from Medtronic, Novo Nordisk, and Johnson & Johnson. He is a member of the data safety monitoring board for GT Metabolic Solutions and has provided scientific advice to Keyron, MetaDeq, GHP Scientific, and ViBo Health for no remuneration. Dr. Busetto discloses relationships with Burno Farmaceutici, Novo Nordisk, PronoKal, Rhythm, and Therascience.
A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.