1. Tan WS, Chow EP, Fairley CK, Chen MY, Bradshaw CS, Read TR. Sensitivity of HIV rapid tests compared to fourth generation enzyme immunoassays or HIV RNA tests - a systematic review and meta-analysis. AIDS. 2016 Apr 27. [Epub ahead of print]
Two-Step ED Urinary Tract Infection Screening Cuts Catheterization Rate in Half
BY TARA HAELLE
FROM PEDIATRICS
fter implementation of a quality improvement initiative to more effectively screen febrile children for UTIs in the ED, catheterization rates dropped from 63% to 30% over a 6-month period, a study found.
The sustained drop prevented more than 350 young children from catheterization without increasing revisit rates or missing UTIs in the 39% of children who were followed in the care network. This was in a study that compared catheterization rates in 1,520 children aged 6 to 24 months in the year before the intervention and 828 children in the 6 months during the intervention.
“Although urine catheterization remains the gold standard in diagnosing UTIs, it is an invasive procedure that may be avoided in most patients who are being screened,” wrote Dr Jane M. Lavelle of Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) and her associates. Screening for UTIs by this method can be “painful, time consuming, and costly,” they added.
An alternative method to automatic catheterization is a two-step process already included as an option in the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines: instead of collecting urine through catheterization just once for screening and culture, an ED first noninvasively collects urine with a urine bag for screening in those indicated with evidence-based risk factors, and then catheterizes only those who screen positive.
“Due to the predictive models’ higher sensitivity than specificity for screening, most urine samples will have a negative screen for pyuria or bacteriuria by urine dipstick or microscopy,” the authors wrote.
At baseline, CHOP’s ED was screening 63% of febrile children under age 24 months using catheterization, but screens were most commonly negative and only 4.3% had positive cultures. The authors therefore initiated a switch to the two-step method as a pilot run in one ED area before educating all ED personnel and expanding to the full department in the second month.
Children aged 6 to 24 months comprised approximately 20% of the ED’s more than 90,000 annual patients, and about 22% of these children presented with fever as the primary concern. Children with a history of genitourinary problems or immune deficiency were excluded.
The pilot ran in an “urgent care section of ED where there are typically more children with less complex medical histories and where ‘fever’ is a common complaint,” the investigators said. The staff completed a learning module with assessment and then received in-person and visual reminders of the procedure.
While 69% of 828 febrile young children still underwent screening during the 6-month intervention period, only 16% still underwent urethral catheterization as the initial screening step, typically because of strong clinical indications for a UTI. Another 14% underwent catheterization only after a positive urine screen from an initial noninvasive urine collection or because of an inability to get an adequate urine specimen with the bag. The reduction in catheterization dropped to 55% within 2 weeks of the intervention’s start and spread to other hospital departments. The drop to a 30% catheterization rate remained throughout 18 additional months of monitoring.
The research did not use external funding, and the researchers reported they had no financial disclosures.
1. Lavelle JM, Blackstone MM, Funari MK, et al. Two-step process for ED UTI screening in febrile young children: reducing catheterization rates. Pediatrics. 2016 Jun 2. pii: e20153023. [Epub ahead of print].